Methodology Match
POSITION

Pragmatism

Where do you stand?

The Pragmatism card
Reality

What we meet through action and its consequences. The world answers back.

Knowledge

Ideas are tools, tested in use. Inquiry starts from a real problem, and making is a way of knowing.

Asks

What works, and what difference does it make?

Key thinkers: John Dewey, William James, Charles Sanders Peirce

The longer story

Pragmatism judges ideas by what they let us do. For Peirce, James and Dewey, thinking is a response to a real difficulty, and knowledge is what we have when a problem has been worked through in practice. Truth is not a mirror of the world; it is what holds up when tested in use.

This makes it a natural home for practice research and design research. Dewey's Art as Experience treats making and perceiving as forms of inquiry, and Schön's reflective practitioner comes straight from this tradition. It is also the usual justification for mixing methods: use whatever answers the question. The risk is using "it works" to avoid asking for whom.

← Hermeneutics All Positions Critical Theory →